Josh Broadwell

IGN

Josh Broadwell·Dec 14, 2022

Critic70/100

Agreement—

A charming, casual spin on the classic RPG series that never quite lives up to its full potential.

Polygon

Josh Broadwell·Nov 2, 2022

Critic—

Agreement—

Comforting but fleeting JRPG storytelling

Nintendo Life

Josh Broadwell·Sep 6, 2022

Critic70/100

Agreement—

Disney Dreamlight Valley is a frictionless, relaxing spin on life sims that manages to remain heartwarming and charming, despite a few Switch-related rough patches. Dreamlight Valley's unique identity relies heavily on fresh interactions with your in-game friends, and Gameloft will need to continue supporting it with regular updates to keep the Night Thorns from creeping back in. However, what's here at launch is surprisingly touching and thoughtful, and cleverly plays on the nostalgia of anyone who's ever been a Disney fan.

Polygon

Josh Broadwell·Aug 16, 2022

Critic—

Agreement0%

A gripping finale can’t save a bland cast and shallow writing

PC Gamer

Josh Broadwell·Feb 18, 2022

Critic70/100

Agreement—

Cheap humor betrays this RPG's smart storytelling and intriguing setting.