CriticMeter

Critic reviews from every outlet CriticMeter tracks. Vote on whether each one matches your take.

Gothic 1 Remake

Xbox Series X, PC, PS5·RPG, Adventure·Single player·Alkimia Interactive·2026

GamesRadar+

Abbie Stone · Jun 5, 2026

“Gothic 1 Remake review-in-progress: "A beautiful remake of a true original, but too much jank made the cut too"”

CriticNo scoreScore available at GamesRadar+ →

Agreement—Not enough votes

Gothic 1 Remake

Xbox Series X, PC, PS5·RPG, Adventure·Single player·Alkimia Interactive·2026

PC Gamer

Jody Macgregor · Jun 5, 2026

“If you thought Kingdom Come: Deliverance was too welcoming, Gothic 1 Remake might be for you.”

Critic60/100PC Gamer's score

Agreement—Not enough votes

eFootball Kick-Off!

Switch 2·Sports·Konami Digital Entertainment·2026

Nintendo Life

Nintendo Life Staff · Jun 3, 2026

“You seen one football game, you've seen Yamal. In a sense, the arrival of eFootball on Switch 2 is something of a homecoming for Konami, whose long-running football series started off as a Nintendo exclusive decades ago. Whether you want to start the timeline with NES game…”

Critic70/100Nintendo Life's score

Agreement—Not enough votes

Final Fantasy VII Rebirth

Xbox Series X, Switch 2, PC, PS5·RPG, Adventure·Single player·Square Enix Creative Business Unit I·2024

Nintendo Life

Nintendo Life Staff · Jun 2, 2026

“The Unknown Journey continues... When Square Enix originally announced that Final Fantasy VII Remake was coming to Switch 2, it came with the promise that Final Fantasy VII Rebirth and its eventual sequel would also be coming. While Remake established itself as one of the finest…”

Critic80/100Nintendo Life's score

Agreement—Not enough votes

007 First Light

Xbox Series X, Switch 2, PC, PS5·Shooter, Adventure·Single player·IO Interactive·2026

Rock Paper Shotgun

Mark Warren · May 30, 2026

“007 First Light is built on the bones of IO Interactive’s Hitman, and makes no effort to hide that fact. But it’s far from just Agent 47 in a wig and doing his best posh English boarding school accent. The section that properly convinced me of this, ironically, is…”

CriticNo scoreRock Paper Shotgun doesn't use numeric scores

Agreement—Not enough votes

Mina the Hollower

Xbox Series X, PC, Switch 2, PS5, Switch·Platformer, RPG, Adventure·Single player·Yacht Club Games·2026

Push Square

Push Square Staff · May 29, 2026

“Anything but a hollow experience. Over a decade since Yacht Club Games made its mark on the indie scene with Shovel Knight, the studio is finally back with its next big nod to retro games, Mina the Hollower. Instead of going the 2D platformer route again, Mina the Hollower lives…”

Critic70/100Push Square's score

Agreement—Not enough votes

007 First Light

Xbox Series X, Switch 2, PC, PS5·Shooter, Adventure·Single player·IO Interactive·2026

Push Square

Push Square Staff · May 29, 2026

“The game's Bond, James Bond. James Bond is undoubtedly one of the most famous names in all of fiction, which is a pretty funny thing to be able to say for a secret agent. With a multitude of books, movies, games, magazines, and countless items of merchandise, the character, and…”

Critic80/100Push Square's score

Agreement100%4 votes · 100% agree

Mina the Hollower

Xbox Series X, PC, Switch 2, PS5, Switch·Platformer, RPG, Adventure·Single player·Yacht Club Games·2026

Eurogamer

Christian Donlan · May 29, 2026

“Here is a game that feels like an adventure. And it feels like it was an adventure to make, too. Mina the Hollower took six years to design and build, six years that took it from what sounds like a kind of coding doodle to a panoramic journey across a richly imagined island,…”

Critic100/100Eurogamer's score

Agreement100%2 votes · 100% agree

007 First Light

Xbox Series X, Switch 2, PC, PS5·Shooter, Adventure·Single player·IO Interactive·2026

PC Gamer

Joshua Wolens · May 29, 2026

“IO's take on the Bond-iverse shines, but not enough to compensate for the very familiar game around it.”

Critic65/100PC Gamer's score

Agreement—Not enough votes

007 First Light

Xbox Series X, Switch 2, PC, PS5·Shooter, Adventure·Single player·IO Interactive·2026

IGN

jon Burgess · May 28, 2026

“Confident and charismatic, James Bond's long-awaited return to games is the best since GoldenEye.”

Critic90/100IGN's score

Agreement75%4 votes · 75% agree

Yoshi and the Mysterious Book

Switch 2·Platformer, Adventure·Single player·Good-Feel·2026

Kotaku

Rebekah Valentine · May 28, 2026

“Even with cute creatures, some extremely creative ideas, and loads to do, there’s something missing at the heart of Yoshi’s latest adventure”

CriticNo scoreKotaku doesn't use numeric scores

Agreement0%1 vote · 0% agree

Warhammer 40,000: Mechanicus II

Xbox Series X, PC, PS5·RPG, Strategy·Single player·Bulwark Studios·2026

PC Gamer

Jody Macgregor · May 28, 2026

“Mechanicus 2 is a decent strategy game, but the original was a vibe, as the kids say-if the kids spent a lot of time playing turn-based tactics games where cybernetic zealots fought robot mummies.”

Critic70/100PC Gamer's score

Agreement—Not enough votes

Paralives

PC·Simulation, Indie·Single player·Alex Massé·2026

IGN

Tom Marks · May 27, 2026

“A rough-around-the-edges life simulator with a striking art style and some promising ideas.”

Critic70/100IGN's score

Agreement100%2 votes · 100% agree

Mina the Hollower

Xbox Series X, PC, Switch 2, PS5, Switch·Platformer, RPG, Adventure·Single player·Yacht Club Games·2026

PC Gamer

Kerry Brunskill · May 27, 2026

“Mina can offer whatever challenge you're up for.”

Critic90/100PC Gamer's score

Agreement100%3 votes · 100% agree

Mina the Hollower

Xbox Series X, PC, Switch 2, PS5, Switch·Platformer, RPG, Adventure·Single player·Yacht Club Games·2026

IGN

Tom Marks · May 27, 2026

“A big game in a small package, and an absolute masterpiece of an adventure.”

Critic100/100IGN's score

Agreement100%2 votes · 100% agree

Mina the Hollower

Xbox Series X, PC, Switch 2, PS5, Switch·Platformer, RPG, Adventure·Single player·Yacht Club Games·2026

GamesRadar+

Dustin Bailey · May 27, 2026

“Mina the Hollower review: "Classic Zelda vibes channel Bloodborne to create one of my new retro-style favorites"”

Critic90/100GamesRadar+'s score

Agreement100%2 votes · 100% agree

Mina the Hollower

Xbox Series X, PC, Switch 2, PS5, Switch·Platformer, RPG, Adventure·Single player·Yacht Club Games·2026

Nintendo Life

Ken Talbot · May 27, 2026

“Yacht Club Games has successfully made the leap from Mario-inspired side-on platforming to Zelda-style adventure, delivering another retro-styled masterpiece. Mina the Hollower is an intricate, challenging yet accessible adventure packed with content, set against a gorgeous 8-bit gothic backdrop.”

Critic90/100Nintendo Life's score

Agreement—Not enough votes

Mina the Hollower

Xbox Series X, PC, Switch 2, PS5, Switch·Platformer, RPG, Adventure·Single player·Yacht Club Games·2026

GameSpot

Steve Watts · May 27, 2026

“With Mina the Hollower, Yacht Club Games has cemented itself as one of the premiere independent studios in the industry today. Its breakout hit, Shovel Knight, was a retro-throwback platformer that merged classic 8-bit-style action with some modern touches. Mina the Hollower…”

Critic90/100GameSpot's score

Agreement—Not enough votes

007 First Light

Xbox Series X, Switch 2, PC, PS5·Shooter, Adventure·Single player·IO Interactive·2026

GamesRadar+

Josh West · May 26, 2026

“007 First Light review: "Bond's greatest game to date, this is a well-oiled spy thriller machine"”

Critic80/100GamesRadar+'s score

Agreement100%3 votes · 100% agree

007 First Light

Xbox Series X, Switch 2, PC, PS5·Shooter, Adventure·Single player·IO Interactive·2026

Kotaku

Jackson Tyler · May 26, 2026

“IO Interactive's James Bond origin story mostly excels as a playable movie but struggles under the weight of some grander ambitions”

CriticNo scoreKotaku doesn't use numeric scores

Agreement0%4 votes · 0% agree

Reviews

Reviews