MLB The Show 25

Push Square

Sammy Barker·Apr 8, 2025

Critic80/100

Agreement—

MLB The Show 25's refinements to Road to the Show and Diamond Dynasty make this another superb baseball sim. The on-field gameplay may feel largely familiar, but it's already so well executed that it staves off any feeling of samey-ness. Some great new modes and another enjoyable set of documentary-esque storylines round out a package that's still quite comfortably at the top of its game.

Game Informer

Brian Shea·Mar 31, 2025

Critic85/100

Agreement—

MLB The Show 25 delivers perhaps the most well-rounded package of any of the mainstream sports video games, making for a title I first fired up during Spring Training and could very well still be playing when the World Series rolls around.

GameSpot

Richard Wakeling·Mar 24, 2025

Critic80/100

Agreement—

MLB The Show 25 adds a number of impactful new features while tweaking its already excellent on-field action

IGN

Justin Koreis·Mar 20, 2025

Critic90/100

Agreement—

Smart additions have brought much needed life back to MLB The Show 25.