Skip to content
criticmeterBETA
Log in

Adam Smith

Reviews71
Outlets1
Avg scoreNo scores
Agreement

Reviews

19 reviews
Political Animals2016
Rock Paper Shotgun logo
Critic
Agreement

After a few campaigns, it’s left me a little cold. Topical it may be, but the lack of engagement with issues and their effects makes it hard for me to see the theme (both animal and political) as much more than a lick of paint on a fairly well-worked but narrow game of numbers. Perhaps that’s what electioneering actually is but if I had to cast my vote, I’d be sticking with the push-and-pull policies of Democracy rather than Political Animals’ detatched campaigns of territorial control.

Read full review at Rock Paper Shotgun
No vote recorded.
Football Manager 20172016
Rock Paper Shotgun logo
Critic
Agreement

You probably already know whether you want a new Football Manager in your life right now. If you do, this is a better option than last year’s edition, particularly given its improvements for those playing long-term saves. It’s evolution not revolution, but that was needed given how much the match engine and transfer intelligence seemed to be creaking after years without a significant tune-up.

Read full review at Rock Paper Shotgun
No vote recorded.
Titanfall 22016
Rock Paper Shotgun logo
Critic
Agreement

If you’re even mildly interested in buying a new multiplayer FPS, you won’t go wrong with this, and if you enjoy smart level design, the singleplayer is vital, though the pricetag is hard to justify given the short running time. None of those ideas I’m refusing to describe so as not to spoil them are going to add replay value either, unless, like me, you’re likely to replay just to show people the spectacle of it all.

Read full review at Rock Paper Shotgun
No vote recorded.
Gonner2016
Rock Paper Shotgun logo
Critic
Agreement

GoNNER is this year’s Downwell – a neat, short-form action game that has found the perfect visual style to communicate its near-misses and big hits. Whether you want to show off by pushing its systems to the limits or play at a more relaxed and careful pace, basking in the gorgeous music, it’s an absolute delight.

Read full review at Rock Paper Shotgun
No vote recorded.
Pro Evolution Soccer 20172016
Rock Paper Shotgun logo
Critic
Agreement

I want to recommend it heartily but I can’t. Not quite. The lack of licenses doesn’t bother me in the slightest – and it really is stripped down, with just two Premier League teams and no Bayern Munich – but the lack of bells and whistles that exist elsewhere in the same game really does. Imagine Lionel Messi playing in that Colardo Caribous strip from back in the day. That’s PES 2017 on PC.

Read full review at Rock Paper Shotgun
No vote recorded.
Offworld Trading Company2016
Rock Paper Shotgun logo
Critic
Agreement

What you need to know is that Mohawk have made a game that creates tension and ruthless competition out of a screen of ever-changing numbers. Every victory feels hard-earned and every defeat can be traced back to specific twists in the tale, and in each of its half hour sessions, there are as many twists as in Civ’s six thousand years.

Read full review at Rock Paper Shotgun
No vote recorded.
Dark Souls III2016
Rock Paper Shotgun logo
Critic
Agreement

If this were to be the final Souls game, I'd be happy to say goodbye. It's not quite the crowning achievement of the series but it's a fantastically inventive and fluid interpretation of the formula. And perhaps that would make it a great first Souls game for somebody new to the series as well.

Read full review at Rock Paper Shotgun
No vote recorded.