Skip to content
criticmeterBETA
Log in

Charlie Wacholz

Reviews24
Outlets3
Avg score71
Agreement

Reviews

24 reviews
Lost Soul Aside2025
IGN logo
IGN
Charlie Wacholz·Sep 8, 2025
Critic50/100
Agreement

Lost Soul Aside’s repetitive story, derivative characters, and bland level design take turns setting up rakes for its excellent combat to step on. This game would be much better without trying to be an RPG.

Read full review at IGN
No vote recorded.
Library of Ruina2021
Nintendo Life logo
Critic40/100
Agreement

We wish we liked Library of Ruina more than we do; its world and characters touch on clever themes and storytelling devices, but never fully lean into its potential. Slapdash pacing coupled with sluggish, nerve-wracking menus makes playing Library of Ruina an exercise in courting digital whiplash as you cycle between rushed, truncated story beats and glacially-paced menus. If it had more engaging combat and a more efficient narrative setup, Library of Ruina would have really impressed us. Sadly, we don't feel very compelled to see it through to completion.

Read full review at Nintendo Life
No vote recorded.
Dave the Diver2023
Nintendo Life logo
Critic90/100
Agreement

In a year dominated by titanic, big-budget releases like Tears of the Kingdom and Mario Wonder, Dave the Diver steps up to the plate and knocks the ball clear of the park with a heaving swing. Its charming animations and writing supplement a mechanically dense experience that never stops dangling a new carrot to chase. It's one of the few games to come out this year that rivals Mario Wonder's all-out density and charm while doing something almost completely new. You owe it to yourself to pick up this outstandingly funny, enthralling, and weird gem.

Read full review at Nintendo Life
No vote recorded.
Gordian Quest2022
Nintendo Life logo
Critic50/100
Agreement

It's deeply disappointing to play Gordian Quest and encounter the amount of UI-driven issues that permeate its menus, because it has some really cool stuff going on beneath its bristly, frustrating outer shell. It's decidedly easier to pick up than most other deckbuilders, and combat has a good flow to it, with lots of combinations and deck variations to explore. Unfortunately, it's a horrendous Switch port that makes even simple things difficult. It's worth your time, just maybe not on the Switch.

Read full review at Nintendo Life
No vote recorded.
Horizon Chase 22022
Nintendo Life logo
Critic60/100
Agreement

Horizon Chase 2 isn't going to set the world on fire. No matter how fun it is to fly across the highway at blazing speed, no amount of speed can disguise the fairly limited breadth of content available. In fact, that speed only makes courses blur together even more. Ultimately, you're left with a fun but shallow arcade racer that feels disappointingly shaky on Switch.

Read full review at Nintendo Life
No vote recorded.