Skip to content
criticmeterBETA
Log in

Graham Smith

Reviews31
Outlets2
Avg scoreNo scores
Agreement

Reviews

31 reviews
Wildfire2020
Rock Paper Shotgun logo
Critic
Agreement

It’s the underlying systems which let everything else down, and which felt incoherent to me. Some games only become fun once you work out what they expect from you, and I spent most of my time with Wildfire wondering if I was playing it wrong. Maybe I was, but if there was a fun way to play it, I never found it.

Read full review at Rock Paper Shotgun
No vote recorded.
The End Is Nigh2017
Rock Paper Shotgun logo
Critic
Agreement

I can't talk about The End Is Nigh without comparing it to Super Meat Boy because in so many ways it feels like a conscious alternative to some of the defining properties of that rapid, colourful, classic game. But measured on its own qualities, The End Is Nigh is a good game, but not a memorable one.

Read full review at Rock Paper Shotgun
No vote recorded.
Brute2017
Rock Paper Shotgun logo
Critic
Agreement

Brute introduces a few twists as you go along that I haven't mentioned here, but doesn't do enough to establish its own identity and step out from underneath the shadow of its inspirations. That doesn't make it any less fun. If you've tired of its inspirations and are looking for something new, then it'll scratch that same itch.

Read full review at Rock Paper Shotgun
No vote recorded.
Everything2017
Rock Paper Shotgun logo
Critic
Agreement

By throwing out most of Spore's traditional mechanics in favour of a cross between Katamari Damacy and Nested, Everything gets closer to sublimity. And though I don't think it gets all the way there – not for me, not right now – the silliness is constant and delightful.

Read full review at Rock Paper Shotgun
No vote recorded.
The Final Station2016
Rock Paper Shotgun logo
Critic
Agreement

The Final Station is a simple game, which is always just compelling enough for its duration. I’ve come to think of it as an efficient, low budget horror movie: it has a high concept it can’t afford to show directly and so it wrings as much as it can from the mystery and the satisfaction of piecing the plot together from snippets. It’s only a shame that its action suffers more from never having a particularly interesting concept of its own.

Read full review at Rock Paper Shotgun
No vote recorded.
Deus Ex: Mankind Divided2016
Rock Paper Shotgun logo
Critic
Agreement

Mankind Divided is a new version of one of my favourite games of all time and free from the execution problems that hampered that last iteration. The levels are bigger and prettier. There are no dumb boss fights. It gives you slightly more agency over its story. The new abilities are nice, even if they don't dramatically alter the flow of the game.

Read full review at Rock Paper Shotgun
No vote recorded.